Predictions-part II

Started by Jarrtail, January 14, 2010, 06:19:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Jarrtail

Now that the official story is done, and we have some epilogues to pine away for, I thought it might be interesting to see how the other members of the audience thought the story would pan out (my original Top Three included Revel, Damask, and Rath  :P), and share many hearty laughs when we realize how wrong we were.

saffy

I thought the top three were gonna be Revel, Damask and Bell, placing in that order. :P Then again, I'm still reading the beginning of week 4, so..

Jarrtail

I'd kind of hoped that Deadtail would have made it farther. I saw him as a sort of improved Greenfang, and rooting for him was the next best thing to getting Greeny (who, by the way, is feeling rather put out due to lack of fanart) in the contest.

Opal

Based on reactions to apps alone, I predicted a Revel, Rath, and Eliza top three early on.

...I was close! :P

I also predicted, based on apps, that Deady would be the last or second to last one eliminated, so not so close on that. I guessed his whole shunning leadership thing would be what made him fall just short (which is stupid because that was his BEST CHARACTER TRAIT YOU MURDERERS ;_;), but it apparently made him fall a bit shorter than expected. XD

Other than that...I hadn't the vaguest idea. It was really interesting to sit back and watch the votes fall into place each week. It was extremely difficult to predict their outcome beforehand. And some weeks there'd be a tie juuust up until the last minute, so it was suspenseful even for me, the one who could actually see the results as they came in. :P
"I've got a plan so cunning you could put a tail on it and call it a weasel." - Blackadder the Third

Cricket Argyll

Based on the initial response to apps: Revel, Eliza, and Venril. As the weeks went by, it became: Rath, Eliza, Venril. Then, when it was down to the final five (before seeing any of the votes for the final three): Bell, Damask, and Eliza. After seeing the actual numbers for the final three, if Damask had stayed, I suspect it would have been: Eliza, Damask, and Revel. I didn't have much hope for a long and fruitful career early on when Su died and Bell was left as the only woodlander. Funny how things turn out, eh?
*crickets chirruping*

Cairn Destop

My thought went to a Eliza - Bellona race right from Week Two.  My biggest concern was the final survivor.  I figured when it got down to five, the winner of the love triangle would become the third.  When Damask was forced to withdraw and Venril died, Revel slipped into the final spot.

I must say that I thought Revel's strategy for survival the best, and possibly the most novel one in Survivor history.  My mind couldn't imagine anyone being so cruel as to kill off a pregnant character.  And before the readers start throwing things my way, let me emphasize that if Revel's writer did not come across as a strong writer, even that could not save her.

Think I can reveal the fact that Revel and I had many long discussions regarding her role.  Regardless of my thoughts, the objective is to be one of the three finalist.  Revel's strategy proved better than mine.  Her finish was well earned.
In life, the only thing that ever adds up is a column of numbers.

Damask the Minstrel

Let me correct that: /most/ have the objective of the top 3. My proof of this is that I intentionally moved to tank the love triangle when we left the caves because I thought it was interfering with the main story and slighting everyone else. Further proof is that we never stopped collaboratively posting. I think that for this group (at least most of us), writing a good story and enjoying ourselves came before competition.
"The story of life - Boy meets girl. Boy gets stupid. Boy and girl live stupidly ever after." -- Dr. James Wilson

Opal

Quote from: Cairn Destop on January 18, 2010, 09:51:54 PM
My mind couldn't imagine anyone being so cruel as to kill off a pregnant character.

Heh, well, it worked on you, it appears! Not necessarily everyone else though, because every contestant received at least one death vote at some point during the contest, even Little Miss Preggers. :P
"I've got a plan so cunning you could put a tail on it and call it a weasel." - Blackadder the Third

Revel

"Little" Miss Preggers?  :D

It wasn't my intention to avoid votes with it really. I just wanted to write a preggo! I also didn't really have getting in the top 3 as a goal. It was enough for me just to get in at all. So thank you everyone who didn't vote for me and thought I was a winner.  :)


My predictions were mostly Rath, Eliza and Bellona.

(I am also writing my epilogue! I got distracted for a week or two but it shouldn't be many more days left now.)
And I hope that you know that nature is so
This same rain that draws you near me
Falls on rivers and land, and forests and sand,
Makes the beautiful world that you'll see in the morning


To all reviewers, past and present, thank you! I don't always find something to say in reply to each reviewer but I do my best to read them and will take their advice as best I can. You are appreciated!

Damask the Minstrel

"because every contestant received at least one death vote at some point during the contest, even Little Miss Preggers"

Unless you throw out Syc's little "I voted for everyone" escapade... then Liza never got a death vote. Lucky dog that she is.
"The story of life - Boy meets girl. Boy gets stupid. Boy and girl live stupidly ever after." -- Dr. James Wilson

Eliza Lacrimosa

Hee!

Well, my initial predictions from reading the apps, before any speculation was something like this:

1st - Revel
2nd - Bellona
3rd - Damask
4th - Rath
5th - Eliza
6th - Keane
7th - Deadtail
8th - Venril
9th - Suellyn

I figured that, with the caliber of writing that was going on, we'd see a pretty strong final six or so, and at that point people would vote me off for being a character who was essentially useless in a survival situation.
She walks in beauty, like the night
of cloudless climes and starry skies;
And all that's best of dark and bright
meet in her aspect and her eyes...


~Lord Byron

Totally still working on the RV5 epilogue, I swear...

Damask the Minstrel

Good gracious.

I think my top 9 looked exactly the same!

Well, except flip Rath and I. I didn't think Dammy would make the top 3.

(But, yeah, as I said during the contest. When we got to the top 5 or 6... it was really anyone's contest, I thought.)
"The story of life - Boy meets girl. Boy gets stupid. Boy and girl live stupidly ever after." -- Dr. James Wilson

Birch

I don't know about you guys (well, actually I do), but mine looked like this:

1. Birch
2. Birch
3. Birch
4. Birch
5. Birch
6. Birch
7. Birch
8. Birch
9. Revel

Jarrtail

Hey, you were supposed to post the next fanfiction chapter about a month ago! Bad Birch! *sprays with water*  ;D

Birch